Technology, Social Media, and Mental Health
What is Causing the Teen Mental Health Crisis?
Interconnected Causes:
-
Overprotection of Children in the Physical World – Reacting to stories of "stranger-danger", adults began moving toward overprotection at home and at school in the late 90's to early 2000's. Overprotection reduces opportunity for kids to experience and adapt to normal stress, which supports tolerance to stress later in life.
-
The Loss of Play-Based Childhood – Imaginative play is essential for optimal child development, and our current generations of children, youth, and young adults have experienced less of it than any known generation before due to overprotection and the rise of "screen-based childhood."
-
Loss of Loosely Supervised Play – Loosely supervised play is another element of childhood that is essential for optimal development, because it creates opportunity for children and youth to adapt to developmentally appropriate stress, and to naturally develop conflict resolution skills.
-
Early/Frequent Access to Smartphones and Social Media – "Screen-based childhood" began to supplant "play-based childhood" when parents began keeping kids home in an attempt to increase safety, and increased with the advent of smartphones with social media apps. The remarkable negative impact of access to smartphones and social media is outlined below.
-
Loss of Close Community – A true community is not just a feeling of connection, but a stable network of overlapping relationships, shared identity, norms, and rituals that foster trust, accountability, and mutual reliance. These structures create belonging while also guiding behavior through shared expectations, role models, and respected authority. When community erodes, individuals lose not only connection but also the social framework that supports resilience, regulates behavior, and sustains collective wellbeing.
(From the resources titled, "The Anxious Generation" and "After Babel" by Jonathan Haidt and Zach Rausch, listed below.)
The Impact of Technology and Social Media on:
-
Academic Performance Research Links
Mental Health and Development Links
What High School Students Say
Resources: Impact of Technology and Social Media
Administrator Toolkit from the Phone-Free Schools Movement – An online toolkit for school administrators and leaders about how to implement phone-free school policies.
I Had No Idea - Cyber Empowerment – An online resource for both educators and parents aimed “to bridge the generational gap and equip adults to guide youth in making informed choices and recognizing online risks.” This resource covers a host of online safety topics from AI, to managing a first cell phone, to online safety risks.
After Babel – This Substack resource is Jonathan Haidt's effort to "think through, in public, the profound psychological and sociological changes that occurred in the 2010s when human social and political life migrated onto platforms curated by a few for-profit companies whose business models drove them to maximize engagement." This link leads to the "About" page, which is the author's recommended starting place for this resource. Frequently updated with new recommendations and research.
The Anxious Generation – In the book, The Anxious Generation (March 2024), Jonathan Haidt lays out the facts about the epidemic of teen mental illness that hit many countries at the same time, and then investigates the nature of childhood, including why children need play and independent exploration. The website contains Educator and Parent Resources to support "restoring play-based childhood."
Generation Tech – Dr. Jean Twenge is one of the foremost researchers on the impact of smartphones and social media on teen and young adult mental health. Click on this link to travel to her Substack full of articles and resource information on that impact. Many articles are "paid access only" but she frequently sends free articles via email with emerging research trends.
Techno Sapiens - Published by Jacqueline Nesi, a clinical psychologist and professor at Brown University, this blog archives her study of how technology and social media impact mental health (especially for teens), and how parents can help their kids navigate it. This resource is full of parent guides, informative articles, and summaries of relevant research.
Let Grow – Nonprofit organization founded with the intention of encouraging families and agencies to emphasize "mixed-age, unstructured free play to develop young people’s ability to work together, make friends, and grow resilient." The site contains FREE School Program Resources for educators, and Parent and Family Resources for at-home activities.
Teens and Tech: What Difference Does Family Structure Make? – A research based guide containing research on the overlap between smartphones, social media, and families from Dr. Jean Twenge and colleagues. Contains recommendations for rules and structure to improve teen and young adult mental health.
The Screenagers Project - An award winning film that probes into the vulnerable corners of family life and depicts the messy struggles over social media, video games, and academics. The film offers solutions on how families can help kids navigate an ever-changing digital world. Read the press release here and watch the movie trailer here.
